Jenni, a rural obese teen with high blood pressure and cholesterol, gets a full medical screening at a university clinic, then goes back home to no services, no community physical acivity. As 18 percent of West Virginia kindergartners arrive at school obese, West Virginia children are sending up clear red flags of future diabetes and heart disease.
“Jenni” is one of thousands of West Virginia children and teenagers whose high blood pressure and weight puts them at risk of future heart disease, diabetes and other chronic diseases. Photo by Lingbing Hang
Click here for original Gazette layout with all photos and charts
By KATE LONG | Feb. 11, 2012 | Charleston Gazette
MORGANTOWN, W.Va. — Jenni, a young teenager, sat on a West Virginia University examining table, twisting her fingers, waiting for the heart doctor. Sitting nearby, her dad patted her arm and closed his eyes.
Her Braxton County doctor had asked for a consultation. Jenni’s blood pressure was spiking.
In a room down the hall, pediatric cardiologist Dr. Bill Neal and his team looked at Jenni’s test results. “Her heart defect’s not a problem now, but her weight is,” Neal said.
Jenni — not her real name — weighed 209 pounds, at about 5 feet tall.
Neal turned to dietitian Leah Woodburn. “We need to bring her weight and blood pressure down,” he said. “You’ve talked with her?”
“She’s a sweetheart,” Woodburn said, “giggles and smiles and a puppy at home. She eats oodles of ramen noodles, and she’s taking in at least 1,000 calories a day in soda pop.
“She thinks she can cut down on soda and the ramen noodles,” Woodburn said. “If she does, she’ll lose weight. Even 500 extra calories a day adds up to a pound of weight gain a week.”
“Physical activity?” Neal asked. Lots of video games and texting, Woodburn said. Otherwise, not much.
Neal sighed. “She’s above the 99th percentile in weight, with high blood pressure and the neck rash that says that she probably already has high insulin resistance. This child is at very high risk of developing Type 2 diabetes.”
He turned to the medical student attached to their team. It would be fairly straightforward to help Jenni, he said, if her county had a public health dietitian or an after-school physical activity program. The problem is, there was nothing affordable to refer her to, near her home.
“This is a huge problem in most rural counties. We have thousands of pre-diabetic, obese children with high blood pressure who need to get physically active,” Neal said. “They need support and follow-up at home.”
“We could prevent a lot of type 2 diabetes if there was a way to get them active,” he said.
Ninety to 95 percent of diabetics have type 2 diabetes, which is preventable through exercise and diet. It used to be called adult-onset diabetes. “Nobody calls it that anymore,” Neal said.
Jenni’s eyes widened as Dr. Neal entered the exam room. He pulled up a chair between her and her father. “The tests show your heart defect isn’t causing you any problem,” Neal said. Jenni’s shoulders sagged in relief. A shy smile spread across her face. Her cheeks turned pink.
“But your weight is a serious concern,” Neal said. “Your high blood pressure is, I think, related to the extra weight you’re carrying.” Jenni drew a deep breath, blushing.
“You’ve talked about this with the dietitian, haven’t you?” Neal said. She nodded. “What do you think you could do to take off some of those pounds? ”
Jenni said she could cut down on soda pop. “And I could walk my puppy,” she said. Her dad reminded her he bought her a video exercise program. “I could play with that more,” she said.
Cutting down on soda pop was the number one priority, she and Neal agreed. “Let’s see if you can lose 10 pounds,” Neal said. “Small steps.”
After the team left the room, dietitian Woodburn shook her head “If we could reduce soda consumption, obesity rates in this state would drop,” she said. “Just that one thing.”
“A 20-ounce Orange Crush has 20 teaspoons of sugar and 250 calories,” she said, “and 500 extra calories every day, for seven days, translates into one pound weight gain and that’s more stress on her heart.”
Ramen noodles are double-fried. They’re second on her hit list.
Your address matters
Jenni and her dad went back to Braxton County, where last year, 26 percent of fifth-graders — 11 and 12-year-olds — had high blood pressure.
Also, 29 percent were obese, according to West Virginia University’s CARDIAC screening data. For children, “obese” means they weigh more than 95 percent of children their age and height in the national norm group.
Braxton County runs slightly above the state average in obesity, and well above the national average of 20 percent for children ages 12 to 19.
“I know we need to do something,” said Sissy Price, Braxton County’s public health nurse. “These kids are on their way to diabetes, but it’s gotten so common for a child to be that heavy, I think people forget it’s dangerous.”
Price, a part-time sanitarian and a part-time administrator hold down the fort at the county’s tiny health department.
“I wish I could tell you we have something for these kids, but we don’t,” she said. There are no after-school physical fitness programs for kids who aren’t on a sports team, she said.
“One of the coaches is trying to raise money to build a community building where families could exercise,” she said. “All we’ve got is Curves and an adult gym that costs $40 a month. Nothing for kids or people who can’t pay $40 a month.”
“This is a real problem in small rural counties especially,” said House of Delegates Majority Leader Brent Boggs, D-Braxton. “In Braxton County, we’ve got a track team with no track. There’s one football field for the entire county youth and one swimming pool that opens only in summer, so we can’t have swim teams. The list goes on and on.”
The county per capita income is $18,263. The county’s 14,890 residents are mostly scattered about deep rural hollers and steep hillsides. A lot of residents drive to other counties for work. Only about 960 people live in Sutton, the county seat.
Sissy Price grew up in Braxton County. “I love this place, its beauty, the friendly people. That’s why I’m here,” she said. “I want to be useful here. At the health department, we do our best with what we have, but it’s a drop in a bucket that doesn’t have many drops.”
Diabetes and heart disease used to top the public health priorities list, she said, but “drugs and meth have pushed everything down the list. Diabetes is about number ten now. Even teenage pregnancy, drugs have pushed that down the list.”
She’d like to help that coach raise money for the community building, but she can’t do that on the job, she said.
Earlier this year, the health department had a dinner so the community could set public health priorities, she said. “They want us to spend most of our time on drug abuse,” she said. “If I do, I don’t have time to organize a program for diabetes prevention or fitness.
“I am one nurse serving 14,900 people, and more people are coming to the health department, but our funds for are being cut. We got a big cut in immunization money. Small counties are struggling.
“I have to keep my eye on our primary mission. I am not letting vaccine-preventable diseases creep into our county. I won’t let our teenage pregnancy rate rise.
“But we shouldn’t have to choose,” she said. “This is public health. To me, helping children be healthy and fit is just as important as keeping people off drugs.”
Kids on drugs could die today, she said, but kids like Jenni could die 20 years from now and undergo expensive treatment before they do. “Why would we help one and not the other?”
‘Lots of kids’
Braxton County isn’t unique. There is very little to help kids like Jenni in most counties, said Emily Murphy, obesity specialist for West Virginia University Extension Service. This is the elephant in the living room, the reality that isn’t often discussed when people talk about solutions for the state’s chronic disease or obesity problems.
“In many counties, there are no programs where you can refer at-risk kids, no after-school physical activity programs, no Y,” Murphy said. “It’s heartbreaking, because with a little exercise, these kids could turn their health around.”
Jenni won’t get much exercise at school. Students at the high school get only one semester of physical education in four years. Middle school kids get 18 weeks per year, 44 minutes every day for 18 weeks, then no PE for the rest of the year.
The school lunch? “I eat with my child at least once a month,” Price said, “and I can’t say the food isn’t fattening.” She pauses. “They’re trying, making progress.” The menu features brown rice, salad and whole wheat rolls, sometimes bean burritos.
Price dreams of a dietitian — “even somebody who comes once a month” — to run groups for families and kids who want to tackle their weight and learn to cook. “None of the kids know how to cook anymore. Lots of parents don’t cook. All they do is reheat stuff.”
She dreams of after-school physical fitness classes for kids — all kids, not just overweight kids — in “a community building with a swimming pool,” she said. “We could share it with two or three other counties, maybe put it at Flatwoods, close to Gilmer County.”
“There’s a lot of folks like myself who have been meeting and talking about how we can remedy this,” Boggs said. “The bottom line is, the public will have to say, ‘This is what we want.’ Because there’s no federal money for it now, and the state can’t fully fund it. So we’d have to come up with our share.”
If Jenni lived in Beckley, she could go to the YMCA cardio workout program for kids. If she lived in Kanawha County, she could find after-school programs. If she went to East Bank Middle School, the school-based health center would help her work on her weight, as part of a West Virginia University research study.
But there are only 8 YMCAs statewide, and Braxton has no school-based health center yet.
Kanawha also has the state’s only multi-week medical program for overweight kids, Charleston Area Medical Center’s eight-week Healthy Kids program. In that program, Jenni would see a dietitian and doctor every week and meet with other kids. She’d try different ways of exercising. The staff would help her fit physical activity into her life.
Healthy Kids has a long waiting list. It takes a year to get in. Fewer than a hundred kids attend.
Jenni also would have been eligible for Camp New You, a free two-week summer camp for pre-diabetic, overweight kids developed at WVU through the CARDIAC project. Camp New You was cancelled last summer for lack of funds.
“I wish we had something for her,” Sissy Price said. “There’s lots of kids that need it.”